Table 2 Performance evaluation of various-sized kidney tumor segmentation according to labeled data ratios in supervised and semi-supervised learning network by kidney tumor size

Methods Network Ratio(%) Balanced accuracy(%)
Labeled Unlabeled Small (tumor<2.3) Medium (2.3≤tumor<4.3) Large (4.3≤tumor<7.4) Extremely Large (7.4≤tumor)
Supervised learning U-Net[24] 100 0 57.7±12.7 62.3±10.5 74.7±13.9 84.8±12.4
25 0 54.9±12.1 58.2±10.0 68.6±14.4 76.9±8.7
nnU-Net[25] 100 0 62.7±14.4 70.3±14.2 87.8±13.5 94.9±3.8
25 0 53.3±8.5 59.1±14.8 75.4±14.8 88.3±11.1
Semi supervised learning MT[23] 25 75 56.4±10.9 60.6±12.0 63.1±12.8 74.0±10.1
MT with Kidney Local Guided Map (Ours) 25 75 88.74±16.0 88.9±14.6 88.2±13.4 78.5±11.1